Conveying clinical equipoise and exploring patient treatment preferences can enhance recruitment and patient understanding. In essence, it demands that true ambivalence toward the efficacy of a novel therapy exists among researchers. Clinical equipoise is the cornerstone of the similarity position. Stated briefly, for purposes of clinical trials, clinical equipoise demands that at the time a clinical trial is being carried out there be a state of genuine scientific uncertainty in the medical community over which of the drugs or treatments being. In short, clinical equipoise means that there is genuine uncertainty in the expert medical community. According to this concept of clinical equipoise, the requirement is satisfied if there is genuine uncertainty within the expert medical community. Equipoise, knowledge and ethics in clinical research and practice. Wma satellite meeting during the 11th world congress of. A fifth issue that is levied against the equipoise standard is the fact that maintaining equipoise promotes premature termination of randomized, clinical trials 4. Is the concept of clinical equipoise still relevant to. A survey was conducted to determine the attitude of clinicians towards a clinical trial and their current practice in managing adults.
Ethics, costs, and the regulation of cancer clinical research david j. Apr 15, 2003 it is widely held that in order to be ethical, clinical trials must satisfy the requirement known as clinical equipoisethat is, a genuine uncertainty and lack of consensus exists within the medical community about whether the investigational treatment evaluated in a clinical trial is as good as or better than standard treatment or. The pdf file you selected should load here if your web browser has a pdf reader plugin installed for example, a recent version of adobe acrobat reader if you would like more information about how to print, save, and work with pdfs, highwire press provides a helpful frequently asked questions about pdfs alternatively, you can download the pdf file directly to your computer, from where it. Clinical equipoise synonyms, clinical equipoise pronunciation, clinical equipoise translation, english dictionary definition of clinical equipoise. A guide for the ethics committee, it was developed mindfully to be relevant and useful to all other categories of professionals entering the clinical trial research area. The ethics of clinical trials, however, demand a characteristic known as clinical equipoise. The intellectual challenges and emotional consequences of.
Full text is available as a scanned copy of the original print version. Full text full text is available as a scanned copy of the original print version. Frieds equipoise requirement dictates that if a physicianresearcher is soliciting a patient to enroll in a randomized clinical trial or. The limits and hazards of clinical equipoise on cardiology. If you do not see its contents the file may be temporarily unavailable at the journal website or you do not have a pdf plugin installed and enabled in your browser. Leila rooshenas, daisy elliott, julia wade, marcus jepson, sangeetha paramasivan, sean strong, caroline wilson, david beard, jane m. Twoyear outcomes after arthroscopic surgery compared to. The value of neuraminidase inhibitors nais in reducing severe clinical outcomes from influenza is debated. Equipoise, knowledge and ethics in clinical research and.
Therapeutic misconception in the ethics of clinical trials. Freedmans concept of equipoise, which he designated as clinical equipoise, considers it to be entirely ethical for individual clinicianinvestigators. To be in equipoise between two treatments, a and b, is to be cognitively indifferent between the statement a is strictly more effective than b and its negation. Links to pubmed are also available for selected references. The ethics of clinical research flashcards quizlet.
If you would like to support the project, please visit the project page, where you can get more details on how you can help, and where you can join the general discussion about philosophy content on wikipedia. Qualitative synthesis of clinicians practices across six randomised controlled trials. Pdf equipoise, or the criterion of honest professional uncertainty in the clinical community, is currently the most widely accepted standard for. Pages original protocol version iii, august 31, 2015 267 final protocol version vii, october 12, 2017 686. A clinical trial to generate better evidence is desirable. This article is within the scope of wikiproject medicine, which recommends that medicinerelated articles follow the manual of style for medicinerelated articles and that biomedical information in any article use highquality medical sources. It serves as a minimum requirement to justify the investigation of a hypothesis, because any therapy believed by. The concept of community equipoise or clinical equipoise refers to the principle that there is no consensus in the clinical community about which treatment is best. Unethical trials of interventions to reduce perinatal transmission.
Clinical equipoise an overview sciencedirect topics. We highly recommend anyone, whether a novice in the clinical trials research area or experienced, wishing to learn. The principle of equipoise states that, when there is uncertainty or conflicting expert opinion about the relative merits of diagnostic, prevention, or treatment options, allocating interventions to individuals in a manner that allows the generation of new knowledge eg, randomization is ethically permissible. Reevaluation of systemic early neuromuscular blockade rose this supplement contains. This is in part due to the diversity in practice patterns across institutions and the enormous range of available. This study focused on the challenges that practitioners encounter in trying to use such communication strategies and how practitioners may inadvertently impede patient recruitment and informed decision making. There are strong advocates for its continued use or demise. Clinical equipoise requires ethical conduct when performing clinical trials that involve assigning patients to different treatment arms. Its considered fragile due to how easy it is to disturb primarily by a simple hunch by the. Jun 01, 2004 it is widely maintained that a clinical trial is ethical only if some form of equipoise between the treatments being compared obtains. However, it is unknown whether uk clinicians would support a placebocontrolled trial.
The ethics of clinical research in the third world. This means that clinical trials are implemented only when, the researchers have substantial uncertainty doubt about the expected impact efficacy of the intervention drug. In particular, when extremely positive results are seen and a boundary is crossed, the data monitoring committee for a randomized study may recommend stopping the trial and. Oct 01, 2010 clinical equipoise defines the ethical standard for including a patient in a clinical trial. Clinical research and the physicianpatient relationship. The concept of clinical equipoise was developed as an ethical justification for carrying out experimental studies on humans. There are at least three reasons why equipoise is unsuitable for mfs. An easy evasion, retorted the excited bride, who had lost her mental equipoise. Clinical equipoise versus scientific rigor in cancer clinical.
How should we understand clinical equipoise when doing. Cardiology has been a leading field in generating evidence through large randomized clinical trials rcts. How should we understand clinical equipoise when doing rcts. Kimmelmann questions whether equipoise should be rethought as. The equipoise criterion was introduced to reduce this dilemma in that it allows to sustain methodological integrity in a trial and to consider the individual benefit for the patient 11. Equipoise is traditionally defined as a state of genuine uncertainty on the relative value of 2 approaches being compared in a trial. However, the practical application of this ethical concept has proven far from straightforward. Oxford handbook of clinical medicine 10th edition pdf free. Request pdf clinical equipoise clinical equipoise is a core concept in the ethics of research involving human participants. Critics on clinical equipoise argue that this concept needs to be transformed to adapt to forward modern health care.
Clinical equipoise is an important concept concerning the state of knowledge about a particular research topic 67. The standard of clinical equipoise is met if there is genuine uncertainty within the expert medical community not necessarily on the part of the individual investigator about the preferred treatment. The term was first used by benjamin freedman in 1987. Learning health systems, clinical equipoise and the ethics of. It is an ethical precondition for the permissibility. Equipoise in rcts means that there has to be genuine. Is rescue therapy ethical in randomized controlled trials.
The ethics of clinical research requires equipoisea state of genuine uncertainty on the part of the clinical investigator regarding the comparative. Get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 1. Personal integrity and social policy, asserts that physicianresearchers have an ethical obligation to be in a state of equipoise during all stages of randomized clinical trials fried 1974, 153. Freedmans use of the word would as opposed to when is evidence that freedmans clinical equipoise does not require actual disagreement.
Conveying equipoise during recruitment for clinical trials. The principle of clinical equipoise is widely endorsed as a foundational ethical requirement governing design and conduct of rcts. It is widely maintained that a clinical trial is ethical only if some form of equipoise between the treatments being compared obtains. Clinical equipoise and the incoherence of research ethics article in journal of medicine and philosophy 322. Social value, clinical equipoise, and research in a public. Clinical equipoise clinical equipoise defines the ethical standard for including a patient in a randomized clinical trial rct. Equipoise in clinical trials circulation research aha journals. The generated document is only available on the computer of the host and participant. Challenges conveying clinical equipoise and exploring.
In public health research, the justification for randomly assigning participants is based on clinical equipoise. Randomised controlled trials are being increasingly used to evaluate new surgical interventions. Equipoise at an individual clinician level individual equipoise can thus be hard to achieveespecially where ingrained clinical practices are under evaluation. Clinical equipoise and the incoherence of research ethics. Hippocrates also described the importance of cleanliness in the management of wounds. Clinical equipoise definition of clinical equipoise by the. This ohcm 10th edition pdf free download has been hosted at microsoft onedrive and mediafire so that you can instantly access the download without any possible hindrance. A synthesis and secondary analysis of multiple qualitative data sets katrina turner 0 john percival 0 jenny donovan 0 david kessler 0 0 university of bristol, bristol, uk pragmatic mental health trials often have a. Others believe that clinical equipoise, reflecting collective professional uncertainty about treatment, is the soundest ethical criterion 2, 3. Clinical equipoise, also known as the principle of equipoise, provides the ethical basis for medical research that involves assigning patients to different treatment arms of a clinical trial. Clinical equipoise was first proposed as a solution to the problem of randomisation 30 years ago. We averaged daily exercise scores using participant reported exertion borg rating of perceived exertion.
This article is within the scope of wikiproject philosophy, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of content related to philosophy on wikipedia. In this part of the article, you will be able to download oxford handbook of clinical medicine 10th edition in a. Participation in a singleblinded pediatric therapeutic. Both users have the option to print or save the pdf file. For clinical trials, the proposed intervention is sometimes based on logic, but mostly on data obtained from in vitro laboratory studies, animal experiments or preliminary serendipitousplanned obser. The tenet of clinical equipoise provides a clear moral foundation to the requirement that the health care of subjects not be disadvantaged by research participation. Please amend the file name when more than one attachment with the same file name would be possible e. Whitney, and razelle kurzrock abstract cancer is the leading cause of death in americans younger than 85 years of age and kills one american every 56 seconds. Clinical equipoise means a genuine uncertainty on the part of the expert medical community about the comparative therapeutic merits of each arm of a clinical trial. Please visit the project page for details or ask questions at wikipedia talk. In short, clinical equipoise means that there is genuine uncertainty in the expert medical community over whether a treatment will be beneficial.
Adds value enhancement of health or knowledge must be derived from the research positive contribution to knowledge about health and well being evaluates diagnostic or therapeutic intervention that could lead to improvements in health or well being focuses on important issues because research funds. Dec, 2011 randomised controlled trials are being increasingly used to evaluate new surgical interventions. Equality in distribution, as of weight, relationship, or emotional forces. There are a number of problematic methodological issues specific to surgical trials, the most important being identifying whether patients are eligible for recruitment into the trial. Is the concept of clinical equipoise still relevant to research. Sep 29, 2019 equipoise thirdperson singular simple present equipoises, present participle equipoising, simple past and past participle equipoised to act or make to act as an equipoise. It is defined as a state of disagreement or uncertainty in the informed, expert medical community about the relative clinical merits of the intervention arms in a trial. The somewhat esoteric content of the theoretical debate is in sharp contrast with the practical issues raised by the discomfort and emotion expressed by. Theoretical equipoise is the balance or the uncertainty of a physician or researcher over the efficiency of two different treatments that they are running in a trial. Feb 19, 2012 clinical equipoise is the cornerstone of the similarity position. We recently concluded a prospective study of patients with.
Clinical equipoise provides the principled basis for medical research involving patients randomly assigned to different treatment arms of a clinical trial, 4 and is considered a necessary feature for clinical service practitioners to ethically enroll patients into clinical trials. A study assessing the clinical equipoise of surgeons faced with clinical scenarios that involved randomizing patients to receive operative or nonoperative treatment found that 77 % of the polled surgeons that routinely performed surgery for fai were willing to recruit patients into a clinical trial that included a nonoperative arm. I believe that a physician is responsible for the actions heshe takes or recommends. This principle is grounded in the ethical motivation that any exante preference for a given option would undermine the interests of those who are offered another. On the necessity of embedding clinical equipoise in the declaration of. Equipoise and the ethics of clinical research nejm dois. A statistical framework for quantifying clinical equipoise. Clinical equipoise defines the ethical standard for including a patient in a clinical trial.
A synthesis and secondary analysis of multiple qualitative data sets katrina turner 0 john percival 0 jenny donovan 0 david kessler 0 0 university of bristol, bristol, uk pragmatic mental health trials often have a usual care arm. Challenges of clinical trial design when there is lack of. It is widely held that in order to be ethical, clinical trials must satisfy the requirement known as clinical equipoisethat is, a genuine uncertainty and lack of consensus exists within the medical community about whether the investigational treatment evaluated in a clinical trial is as good as or better than standard treatment or. I show how a proper understanding of clinical equipoise can reconcile this conception of rar with these five ethical principles. Clinical and personal equipoise exists when a clinician has no good basis for a choice between two or more care options or when one is truly uncertain about the overall benefit or harm offered by. Government was unnerved, confounded, and in a manner suspended. Clinical equipoise versus scientific rigor in cancer. Because lack of equipoise prior to an rct often leads to the failure of otherwise welldesigned trials 20, efforts to establish or document clinical equipoise are often worthwhile 21.
229 103 282 1310 1157 1196 56 1372 1517 1077 454 480 655 1098 1378 1389 1115 1417 1103 62 21 437 1344 1574 449 518 797 1514 448 694 827 836 682 1353 1027 212 362 1056 814 987 557 28 35 500 778